Best Calamari in Hyde Park, Chicago
The 9 top-rated calamari in Hyde Park, Chicago, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is calamari (all varieties) at Nella Pizza e Pasta (1125 E 55th St), with a flavor score of 87 out of 100 from 54 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
Best Calamari across Chicago→- Ranked #1At Nella Pizza e Pasta1125 E 55th St
Tender calamari, praised for its light, crispy texture and perfect seasoning, pairs well with various delicious dishes.
- Ranked #2At Pizza Capri Hyde Park1501 E 53rd St
Calamari is praised for its great flavor and texture, though some found it overcooked and greasy with burnt oil.
- Ranked #3At Pizza Capri Hyde Park1501 E 53rd St
Grilled calamari is praised for its charred flavor and acidity, though some found the portion size small or inconsistent.
- Ranked #4At Nella Pizza e Pasta1125 E 55th St
- Ranked #5At Nella Pizza e Pasta1125 E 55th St
- Ranked #6At Medici On 57th1327 E 57th St
Calamari is generously portioned and comes with a tasty marinara sauce, but the breading lacks crunch and seasoning.
- Ranked #7At Chant Restaurant In Hyde Park1509 E 53rd St
Calamari was consistently criticized for being rubbery, tough, and lacking flavor, leading to widespread disappointment among diners.
- Ranked #8At Pizza Capri Hyde Park1501 E 53rd St
- Ranked #9At Giordano's5311 S Blackstone Ave
The calamari was criticized for being rubbery, fishy, and lacking seasoning, disappointing many who expected a better dish.