The coconut caramel cookie is praised for its buttery richness and perfect balance of flavors, making it a must-try.

Thick and gooey, the dark chocolate chip cookies feature rich, fudgy centers and melting chocolate chips in every bite.

The cookies are massive, soft, and flavorful, with options like blueberry crumble and chocolate chip that leave a lasting impression.

Chocolate walnut cookies are praised for their rich, nutty flavor and chunky texture, often described as thick and decadent.

Dark chocolate peanut butter chip cookies are praised for their crispy exterior and gooey center, though some found them overly sweet or served cold.

Pignoli cookies are praised for their chewy texture, rich almond flavor, and delightful crunch from the pine nuts.

cookies+2

Warm, soft cookies with rich chocolate flavor and a variety of options are consistently praised for their freshness and deliciousness.

Chocolate peanut butter cookies are praised for their rich flavor, gooey centers, and thick, chewy texture reminiscent of a brownie.

The cookies are praised for their fresh taste and variety, with favorites like pine nut and fig cookies standing out.

The lemon cookie is praised for its warm, dense texture and perfect balance of lemon flavor, making it a standout treat.

The compost cookie combines chocolate chips, pretzels, and butterscotch, praised for its chewy texture and rich flavor.

Fig cookies feature a mildly sweet filling and a cakey texture, though some found them unexpectedly moist and not to their taste.

cookies+1

Delicious cookies with rich flavors like raspberry and peanut butter, praised for their perfect pairing with coffee and special occasions.

Dark chocolate peppermint cookies are gooey and rich with a strong peppermint flavor, though some found them overly sweet.

cookies (all varieties)

+1

Cookies have a soft texture with a mix of flavors, but many found them dry and overpriced compared to other options.

italian cookies+1

Italian cookies are praised for their variety and flavor, though some noted freshness could improve and service issues arose.

Double chocolate chip cookies are thick and rich with a crispy exterior, though some found them overly sweet or too chocolatey.

The dark chocolate chocolate chip cookies are thick and gooey with rich flavor, though some found them overly sweet and pricey.

Levain cookies are praised for their chewy texture and gooey chocolate chips, though some find them overly sweet or lacking flavor.

Double chocolate cookies are praised for their gooey texture and rich flavor, but many find them overly sweet and inconsistent.

Lemon knots are praised for their flavor and freshness, but some found them dry and inconsistent in quality.

Dark chocolate peanut butter cookies are thick and gooey with rich flavor, though some found them burnt or crumbly.

Coffee is often served at an excessively hot temperature and has a bitter taste that many find unappealing.

The cookies are praised for their great flavor and texture, though some found them overly sweet or burnt.

The macarons were often described as hard, chewy, or stale, detracting from the overall afternoon tea experience.