Caprarius

Crowning the Greatest of All Tastes

Caprarius

Crowning the Greatest of All Tastes

Explore
Graze Reports
About
Merch
Terms
Privacy
@caprarius.app

© 2026 Caprarius. Crowning the Greatest of All Tastes.

Best Desserts in New Lenox, IL — Caprarius

Best Desserts in New Lenox, IL

Explore/
New Lenox, IL

Best Desserts in New Lenox, IL

The 42 top-rated desserts in New Lenox, IL, ranked by flavor score.

desserts (all varieties)
Paisano’s Pizza & Restaurant350 W Maple St
2
desserts (all varieties)
Don Jose’s Cantina & Taqueria1080 E Lincoln Hwy
Desserts are consistently praised for their delicious flavors, making them a must-try to end the meal.
3
carrot cake
Williamson's Restaurant & Bar1490 W Maple St
Moist and generous portions of carrot cake with balanced cream cheese frosting leave everyone raving and wanting more.
4
gelato
Joey’s Red HotsSouthwest Suburbs, 217 E Maple St
Creamy gelato with a variety of delicious flavors, including coconut and apple pie, consistently impresses customers.
5
desserts (all varieties)
Sugar Shack Cookie Co280 E Lincoln Hwy
6
desserts (all varieties)
Williamson's Restaurant & Bar1490 W Maple St
7
horchata gelato
Don Jose’s Cantina & Taqueria1080 E Lincoln Hwy
8
desserts (all varieties)
Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant2307 E Lincoln Hwy
Desserts are described as delicious and beautifully crafted, leaving a lasting impression on guests celebrating special occasions.
9
churros
Don Jose’s Cantina & Taqueria1080 E Lincoln Hwy
10
pecan bars
Sugar Shack Cookie Co280 E Lincoln Hwy
11
italian ice
Joey’s Red HotsSouthwest Suburbs, 217 E Maple St
12
cheesecake
Paisano’s Pizza & Restaurant350 W Maple St
Homemade cheesecake with various flavors, especially turtle, receives high praise for its creamy texture and rich taste.
13
key lime pie
Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant2307 E Lincoln Hwy
14
cherry almond bars
Sugar Shack Cookie Co280 E Lincoln Hwy
15
fried oreos
Tom Kelly's495 Degroate Rd
16
banana pudding
Sugar Shack Cookie Co280 E Lincoln Hwy
17
desserts (all varieties)
Oy’s Thai Cuisine1880 E Lincoln Hwy
18
fruit tart
Sugar Shack Cookie Co280 E Lincoln Hwy
19
chocolate cake
Williamson's Restaurant & Bar1490 W Maple St
20
mango sticky rice
Oy’s Thai Cuisine1880 E Lincoln Hwy
21
rice krispie treats
Sugar Shack Cookie Co280 E Lincoln Hwy
22
desserts (all varieties)
Gatto's Italian Restaurant & Bar1938 E Lincoln Hwy
23
pies
Fleckenstein's Bakery352 W Maple St Ste E
24
macarons
Sugar Shack Cookie Co280 E Lincoln Hwy
25
crème brûlée
Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant2307 E Lincoln Hwy
26
custard
Culver’s421 E Lincoln Hwy
Smooth and decadent custard garners rave reviews, though many criticize the small portions and high prices.
27
truffles
Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant2307 E Lincoln Hwy
28
desserts (all varieties)
Aji Sushi651 E Lincoln Hwy
29
desserts (all varieties)
Tom Kelly's495 Degroate Rd
30
cookies
Potbelly571 E Lincoln Hwy
31
chocolate cake
Portillo's New Lenox2306 E Lincoln Hwy
Chocolate cake has a rich, moist flavor that many enjoy, though some criticize its small size and excessive frosting.
32
desserts (all varieties)
Culver’s421 E Lincoln Hwy
33
desserts (all varieties)
Chili's Grill & Bar2390 E Lincoln Hwy
Desserts like the molten chocolate cake receive high praise for their richness, but some found other options disappointing or poorly prepared.
34
frosty
Wendy's2430 E Lincoln Hwy
The Frosty often arrives soupy and barely frozen, disappointing many despite some positive comments about its taste.
35
lemon cake
Portillo's New Lenox2306 E Lincoln Hwy
36
cakes
Portillo's New Lenox2306 E Lincoln Hwy
The cake was criticized for being bland, dry, and of poor quality, disappointing those who remembered it fondly.
37
cannolis
Gatto's Italian Restaurant & Bar1938 E Lincoln Hwy
38
ice cream
Culver’s421 E Lincoln Hwy
Melted ice cream served consistently, slow service, and cold food left many feeling disappointed with their experience.
39
cookies
Jimmy John's2334 E Lincoln Hwy
40
ice cream sundae
Culver’s421 E Lincoln Hwy
41
cinnamon twists
Taco Bell420 W Maple St
42
concrete mixers
Culver’s421 E Lincoln Hwy

Which one is the GOAT?

You can crown one per category, so choose wisely.

More in New Lenox, IL

Sandwiches Appetizers Meat & Poultry Lunch & Dinner Sides Comfort Food & Classics Burgers Tacos Salads Pizzas Soups Pastas Steaks Seafood American Chinese Classics BBQ

Best Desserts in other cities

Chicago Evanston Oak Park Issaquah Oak Brook Northbrook La Grange Elmhurst Evergreen Park Hinsdale Western Springs Brookfield Riverside Clarendon Hills La Grange Park