
Best Pastas in Evanston, IL
The 58 top-rated pastas in Evanston, IL, ranked by flavor score.
- Campagnola815 Chicago Ave
Fresh pasta dishes impress with rich flavors and perfect portions, making them a favorite among diners.
- 2Dave's Italian Kitchen815 Noyes St
- 3Trattoria D.O.C.706 Main St
- 4Trattoria Demi1571 Sherman Ave
Asiago gnocchi is praised for its fluffy texture and creamy tomato sauce, making it a comforting favorite among diners.
- 5Trattoria Demi1571 Sherman Ave
- 6Trattoria Demi1571 Sherman Ave
Homemade pasta cooked to perfection, with rich sauces and generous portions, consistently delights diners seeking comforting Italian flavors.
- 7Panino's Pizzeria1968 Dempster St
The pasta dishes are praised for their generous portions, fresh ingredients, and consistent deliciousness, making them a favorite among customers.
- 8Campagnola815 Chicago Ave
- 9The Barn Steakhouse1016 Church St Rear
- 10Campagnola815 Chicago Ave
The bolognese features rich, flavorful sauce that leaves diners licking their plates, complemented by perfectly cooked pasta.
- 11Trattoria Demi1571 Sherman Ave
- 12Trattoria D.O.C.706 Main St
Pasta dishes are consistently praised for their fresh ingredients, authentic flavors, and perfect cooking, making them a highlight of the menu.
- 13Blind Faith Cafe525 Dempster St
- 14Campagnola815 Chicago Ave
- 15The Barn Steakhouse1016 Church St Rear
Bison Bolognese features rich, flavorful sauce over perfectly al dente pasta, earning praise for its deliciousness and satisfying portions.
- 16Dave's Italian Kitchen815 Noyes St
Lasagna features generous portions and good flavor, but some found it greasy or underwhelming compared to authentic Italian standards.
- 17Campagnola815 Chicago Ave
Pappardelle bolognese features rich meat sauce and wide noodles, but some found it slightly overcooked and portions small.
- 18Blind Faith Cafe525 Dempster St
- 19Trattoria D.O.C.706 Main St
- 20Trattoria D.O.C.706 Main St
- 21Dave's Italian Kitchen815 Noyes St
Pasta dishes have generous portions and good flavors, but some found them overcooked or lacking in seasoning.
- 22Dave's Italian Kitchen815 Noyes St
- 23Trattoria Demi1571 Sherman Ave
- 24The Barn Steakhouse1016 Church St Rear
Crab spaghetti features plenty of lump crab and a buttery garlic sauce, though some found it dry or unremarkable.
- 25Trattoria D.O.C.706 Main St
Lasagna features thin homemade pasta and flavorful sauce, though some found it undercooked or lacking seasoning at times.
- 26Trattoria D.O.C.706 Main St
Spaghetti carbonara features tender pancetta and egg yolk sauce, but some found it overly salty or with gristle.
- 27Campagnola815 Chicago Ave
- 28Trattoria Demi1571 Sherman Ave
- 29Pasta Luna1635 Chicago Ave
Pasta dishes are praised for their great flavor and quality, though some found them oily or lacking sauce.
- 30Dave's Italian Kitchen815 Noyes St
Creamy carbonara with good portion size receives praise, though some found it chunky, lacking flavor, or with unwanted ingredients.
- 31Trattoria D.O.C.706 Main St
- 32Campagnola815 Chicago Ave
- 33Dave's Italian Kitchen815 Noyes St
- 34Evanston Corner Bistro703 Church St
- 35Blind Faith Cafe525 Dempster St
- 36Noodles and Company930 Church St
- 37Campagnola815 Chicago Ave
Tagliatelle features a rich mushroom sauce and savory flavors, but some found it overly mushroomy or lacking in balance.
- 38Trattoria Demi1571 Sherman Ave
Gnocchi is praised for its homemade texture and flavor, but some found it reminiscent of Kraft macaroni and cheese.
- 39Ten Mile House1700 Central St
- 40Union Pizzeria-Evanston1245 Chicago Ave
- 41Lou Malnati's Pizzeria1850 Sherman Ave
- 42Trattoria D.O.C.706 Main St
The carbonara often suffers from excessive grease, lack of seasoning, and inconsistent quality, disappointing many who expected better.
- 43Trattoria Demi1571 Sherman Ave
- 44Prairie Moon1635 Chicago Ave
- 45Cupitol Coffee & Eatery (Evanston)812 Grove St
- 46Noodles and Company930 Church St
- 47Rosati's Pizza1168 Dodge Ave
- 48Sarpino's Pizzeria2428 Main St
- 49Lou Malnati's Pizzeria1850 Sherman Ave
- 50Sarpino's Pizzeria2428 Main St
- 51Trattoria Demi1571 Sherman Ave
The lasagna often lacked flavor, with some describing it as flat, runny, and reminiscent of a low-quality dish.
- 52Noodles and Company930 Church St
- 53The Barn Steakhouse1016 Church St Rear
- 54Noodles and Company930 Church St
Noodles often arrive undercooked and greasy, with many dishes lacking flavor, freshness, and adequate portions.
- 55Trattoria D.O.C.706 Main St
- 56Blind Faith Cafe525 Dempster St
- 57Dave's Italian Kitchen815 Noyes St
- 58Evanston Chicken Shack1925 Ridge Ave
The spaghetti lacked flavor and left diners disappointed, with some even suggesting it needed significant improvement.