Best Cakes in New Lenox, IL
The 6 top-rated cakes in New Lenox, IL, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is cakes (all varieties) at Sugar Shack Cookie Co (280 E Lincoln Hwy), with a flavor score of 98 out of 100 from 81 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
- Ranked #1At Sugar Shack Cookie Co280 E Lincoln Hwy
Cakes are light, fluffy, and beautifully decorated, often featuring rich Italian Buttercream that keeps customers returning for more.
- Ranked #2At Sugar Shack Cookie Co280 E Lincoln Hwy
Beautifully decorated cupcakes with amazing flavors consistently impress, making them a hit for celebrations and everyday treats.
- Ranked #3At Fleckenstein's Bakery352 W Maple St Ste E
Cakes are consistently praised for their delicious flavors, beautiful designs, and freshness, making them perfect for special occasions.
- Ranked #4At Sugar Shack Cookie Co280 E Lincoln Hwy
- Ranked #5At Fleckenstein's Bakery352 W Maple St Ste E
Cupcakes are praised for being moist and delicious, but some found inconsistencies in size and freshness.
- Ranked #6At Fleckenstein's Bakery352 W Maple St Ste E