Best Margaritas in Near South Side, Chicago
The 11 top-rated margaritas in Near South Side, Chicago, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is margarita at Casa Tulum (1700s S Michigan Ave), with a flavor score of 87 out of 100 from 31 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
Best Margaritas across Chicago→- Ranked #1At Casa Tulum1700s S Michigan Ave
The guava margarita stands out for its vibrant flavor, while classic options are praised for being strong and delicious.
- Ranked #2At Chicago Oyster House1933 S Indiana Ave
- Ranked #3At La Cantina Grill1911 S Michigan Ave
The margaritas, especially the tamarind and jalapeño versions, are consistently praised for being strong, fresh, and deliciously flavorful.
- Ranked #4At La Calle Tacos y Tequila67 E Cermak Rd
The classic margarita impresses with fresh ingredients and perfect balance, making it a favorite among visitors.
- Ranked #5At La Cantina Grill1911 S Michigan Ave
The grapefruit margarita is praised for its refreshing taste, perfect balance, and strong flavor, making it a favorite among patrons.
- Ranked #6At AO Hawaiian Hideout1315 S Wabash Ave
The margaritas are praised for being strong and delicious, though some found them inconsistent and not worth the price.
- Ranked #7At La Cantina Grill1911 S Michigan Ave
- Ranked #8At Tapas Valencia Restaurant1530 S State St
The spicy margarita and cucumber cocktail received praise for flavor, but some found the drink options too sugary and overpriced.
- Ranked #9At VU Rooftop133 E Cermak Rd
- Ranked #10At The Bureau Bar and Restaurant2115 S State St