Best Pizzas in Humboldt Park, Chicago
The 10 top-rated pizzas in Humboldt Park, Chicago, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is pizza (all varieties) at Elliots Augusta Pizza & Grill (4400 W Augusta Blvd), with a flavor score of 83 out of 100 from 142 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
Best Pizzas across Chicago→- Ranked #1At Elliots Augusta Pizza & Grill4400 W Augusta Blvd
The pizza features large, delicious slices with great flavors and offers excellent value, making it a favorite among locals.
- Ranked #2At New Best Sub3334 W Chicago Ave
- Ranked #3At New Best Sub3334 W Chicago Ave
- Ranked #4At Elliots Augusta Pizza & Grill4400 W Augusta Blvd
The chicken pizza features deliciously grilled, seasoned chicken on a homemade-style crust, earning high praise from loyal fans.
- Ranked #5At Elliots Augusta Pizza & Grill4400 W Augusta Blvd
- Ranked #6At The New Congress Pizza3737 W Grand Ave
The pizza has good flavor but suffers from inconsistent quality, poor customer service, and delivery issues that frustrate many.
- Ranked #7At Little Caesars Pizza3337B W. North Ave
The pizza was often undercooked, bland, and dry, with long wait times and concerns about food safety.
- Ranked #8At Little Caesars Pizza3337B W. North Ave
- Ranked #9At The New Congress Pizza3737 W Grand Ave
- Ranked #10At The New Congress Pizza3737 W Grand Ave