Best Pastries in New Lenox, IL
The 6 top-rated pastries in New Lenox, IL, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is homemade poptarts at Sugar Shack Cookie Co (280 E Lincoln Hwy), with a flavor score of 89 out of 100 from 6 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
- Ranked #1At Sugar Shack Cookie Co280 E Lincoln Hwy
- Ranked #2At Sugar Shack Cookie Co280 E Lincoln Hwy
- Ranked #3At Fleckenstein's Bakery352 W Maple St Ste E
Pastries are fresh and delicious, especially the maple donuts, though some felt they looked better than they tasted.
- Ranked #4At Sugar Shack Cookie Co280 E Lincoln Hwy
- Ranked #5At Sugar Shack Cookie Co280 E Lincoln Hwy
Flaky crust and perfectly portioned, the pop tarts are deliciously stuffed and loved by everyone who tries them.
- Ranked #6At Fleckenstein's Bakery352 W Maple St Ste E
Delicious Danish, especially the cheese variety, are praised for their flavor and quality, even when enjoyed a day later.